Jose Romero

← Back to the post

The privacy iceberg
Open full page ↗
Interactive companion to the video

The privacy iceberg

How private can you be when you are this public? I went through 32 videos from people who teach this stuff, the guides they point to, and a bunch of forum threads from people who went too deep and burned out. Click through every layer: what it does, what it costs you and who it is for. Then sort your own life into three boxes.

Dive through the layers

Pick a layer on the iceberg. Most of us are going to land somewhere in between the top and the bottom.

Click or tap a layer. With a keyboard, use Tab and Enter, or the up and down arrows.

Above the waterStart hereThreat model first

Know what you are protecting

Before any tools, one question: what am I protecting, and who am I protecting it from?

What it costs

Time
Money
Friction

Who it is for

Everyone, before buying anything.

Costs on a scale of 1 to 5, my working estimates.

What to do

  • Write a quick threat modelThe EFF's list is six questions now, not five: what do I want to protect, who do I want to protect it from, how bad is it if I fail, how likely is it, how much trouble am I willing to go through, and who are my allies.
  • Search yourselfLook yourself up like a stranger would: your name, your usernames, your phone number, plus people-search sites.
  • Check breach exposureRun every email you use through Have I Been Pwned.
My take

The allies question matters more than it sounds. Your family's photos are on your phone and your friends' numbers are in your contacts. If you get sloppy, they are along for the ride.

Notes and sources
From the research

A speaker at a BSides security conference built a full profile on one person (address, phone and birthday) starting from a public staff list. It took him 12 minutes.

The tipLayer 1 of 8Ten-minute wins

Lock the front door

The stuff everybody should be doing. It stops the automated attacks that hit almost everyone.

What it costs

Time
Money
Friction

Who it is for

Everyone. No exceptions.

Costs on a scale of 1 to 5, my working estimates.

What to do

  • Automatic updates on everythingPhone, computer, router, browser.
  • A password manager, with a different password for every accountProtectedLong is what matters, not complicated. Current NIST guidance says at least 15 characters if a password is the only thing protecting the account, and to stop forcing password changes on a schedule.
  • Two-factor everywhere you canProtectedAn authenticator app is better than a text message, and a text message is still better than nothing.
  • Disk encryption and a real passcodeProtectedEncrypt the disk on your laptop (FileVault, BitLocker or LUKS) and put a real passcode on your phone.
  • Back up the things you would cry aboutProtectedStart with one automatic backup. Perfect comes later.
Notes and sources
Why the boring stuff matters

Most attacks have nothing to do with you personally. The UK's National Cyber Security Centre says the majority of attacks are untargeted and opportunistic. It is a robot trying a million doors. If yours is locked, it moves on to the next one.

Just underLayer 2 of 8An afternoon

Tidy up

Phishing-proof logins and fewer copies of you lying around. About an afternoon of work, not a weekend.

What it costs

Time
Money
Friction

Who it is for

Anyone with money, a business or an audience.

Costs on a scale of 1 to 5, my working estimates.

What to do

  • A security key or passkey on your emailProtectedEmail goes first, because whoever gets into your email can reset pretty much everything else. Buy two keys and keep one somewhere safe.
  • Print your recovery codesOff the mapKeep them on paper, offline. This is the first thing on the iceberg that lives completely off the map.
  • Turn on your carrier's number lockProtectedSo nobody can move your number over to their SIM card.
  • Freeze your creditProtectedIn the US it is free to freeze and free to unfreeze at all three bureaus.
  • Email aliases for sign-upsProtectedIf there is a leak, you know exactly who leaked it.
  • Opt out of data brokersProtectedCalifornia has a free state tool called DROP that sends one deletion request to every registered broker. Everywhere else it is site by site. The listings come back, so this is one you have to keep up with.
  • Signal for the conversations that matterProtectedEnd-to-end encrypted messaging.
  • A content blockerFewer trackers and fewer bad ads. It turned into a security tool in October 2026, after Citizen Lab reported spyware delivered through targeted ads.
  • Strip photo metadata before postingPublicGPS data inside a photo is a home address.
If you want a hardware key

A security key like the YubiKey 5C NFC plugs into USB-C and taps over NFC. The cheaper Yubico Security Key C NFC does passkeys and security key login only, with no authenticator app codes. Whichever one you pick, buy two.

My take

If you stop right here, you are already ahead of most people.

Notes and sources
From the research

Consumer Reports found that opting out of data brokers by hand worked better than most of the paid removal services. It was a small study.

Murky waterLayer 3 of 8Compartmentalize

Split your identities

The public you and the private you never share a username, an email, a number or a card. It is a habit, not a purchase.

What it costs

Time
Money
Friction

Who it is for

Creators, anyone with a public name, anyone who has been harassed.

Costs on a scale of 1 to 5, my working estimates.

What to do

  • Never reuse an identifier across your worldsPublicUsername, email, phone number, profile picture, even your writing style. One reused username links your public account to your old forum posts.
  • A secret email used only for moneyProtectedNever typed anywhere public.
  • A business address, number and inboxPublicA mailbox service instead of your house, a registered agent so your home address never lands on company filings, and a business phone number and inbox separate from your real ones.
  • Separate profiles or devicesProtectedBanking and account admin away from the device that installs everything.
  • Split the home networkProtectedSmart TVs, cameras and smart plugs go on their own network, away from your computers. They have no business talking to your laptop.
  • Family stays out of the public graphOff the mapDo not follow, tag or show them from the public account.
  • A rule for every frame you publishPublicWindows, reflections, mail, license plates, the view out the back.
  • Post later, not livePublicNever share where you are while you are still there.
My take

This is the layer that matters most if you have any kind of public life.

Notes and sources
Connecting dots, not hacking

The privacy creator foci tried this on himself. He had mentioned his first name, his city and that he works at a university. Those three facts led to his staff page, then his full name, then his private Instagram. His words: "so much for separating my YouTube."

It is not paranoia

A man in Japan found a singer's home from the train station reflected in her eyes in a selfie. Journalist Taylor Lorenz, who has dealt with a lot of doxxing attempts, said on a livestream that family is often the weakest point, and that she never posts where she is while she is still there.

Getting coldLayer 4 of 8De-cloud the personal stuff

Own your data

If a company cannot read your files, it cannot sell them, leak them or scan them.

What it costs

Time
Money
Friction

Who it is for

People with family photos, documents and a little patience.

Costs on a scale of 1 to 5, my working estimates.

What to do

  • Turn on end-to-end encrypted cloud storageProtectedOn an iPhone, Advanced Data Protection end-to-end encrypts most of iCloud, including photos and backups. Mail, contacts and calendars still are not covered, and new users in the UK cannot turn it on right now.
  • Bring the family photos homeProtectedImmich is a self-hosted replacement for Google Photos. Ente is an end-to-end encrypted service if you do not want to run a server.
  • Local AI for private questionsProtectedA private question to a model on your own machine never leaves the room.
  • 3-2-1 backupsProtectedThree copies, on two kinds of storage, with one of them somewhere else.
  • Delete what you do not needThe safest data is data you never kept.
  • Keep self-hosted apps off the open internetProtectedOwning the data means owning the attack surface too.
The catch

Owning your data also means you own the risk. If your photo server dies and you have no backup, the memories you were trying to protect are gone.

Notes and sources
The real issue with big clouds

Anything that is not end-to-end encrypted can be read by the provider's systems, and one automated mistake can lock you out of your whole account. Immich has been stable since October 2025.

Deep blueLayer 5 of 8Change your tools

Harden the machines

This is where people start swapping out their operating systems.

What it costs

Time
Money
Friction

Who it is for

Tinkerers, journalists, people with an actual adversary.

Costs on a scale of 1 to 5, my working estimates.

What to do

  • A hardened phoneProtectedGrapheneOS on a Pixel. Armor, not an invisibility cloak.
  • Linux on the desktopProtectedFewer phone-home defaults.
  • Filtering DNS for the whole houseProtectedBlock tracker and malware domains for every device at once.
  • A VPN for specific jobsIt hides your traffic from the coffee shop and from your internet provider. It does not make you anonymous.
  • Tor when it mattersOverkill for most days, essential for some.
Notes and sources
The catch down here

The more you tweak your browser, the more unique it gets, and unique is trackable. All that hardening can make you stand out more. This is also where the forums fill up with people who are exhausted.

The dark zoneLayer 6 of 8Assume breach

Isolate

The mindset is a little bleak: you assume you are going to get hacked, and keep the important stuff where a hack cannot reach.

What it costs

Time
Money
Friction

Who it is for

Anyone guarding one thing that must never leak.

Costs on a scale of 1 to 5, my working estimates.

What to do

  • Qubes OS vaultsOff the mapQubes splits your computer into separate virtual machines, and the vault one has no network at all.
  • Tails for sessions that forgetIt runs off a USB stick and forgets everything when you shut it down.
  • An air-gapped computerOff the mapThe real deal: a machine that never touches a network again.
  • One dedicated USB stickOff the mapPlain files only, and it only moves in one direction.
  • Paper or metal, not a fileOff the mapRecovery codes and seed phrases do not need to be digital at all.
Notes and sources
From the research

David Bombal put it simply in his Qubes OS video: if something sensitive does not need the internet, why is it on an internet-connected device? And what the security people say about air gaps is that the weak point is always the USB stick, never the gap. Stuxnet got into an air-gapped uranium enrichment plant on a USB drive.

What the forums say

A full air gap is theater if nobody is targeting you. An offline copy of a few important documents is the real win.

The abyssLayer 7 of 8Physical and legal privacy

Vanish

Michael Bazzell territory. All of it is legal, it is very expensive, and it completely changes how you live.

What it costs

Time
Money
Friction

Who it is for

Stalking victims, high-risk people, the extremely determined.

Costs on a scale of 1 to 5, my working estimates.

What to do

  • Your house is owned by a trustOff the mapThe property record does not lead to you. This needs an attorney.
  • Your utilities are not in your nameOff the mapLegal setups only. Giving a fake name to the government is illegal in many places, and it is not a privacy tip.
  • You pay cash for everythingOff the mapNo purchase history to buy or breach.
  • Your phone never comes home with youOff the mapA phone that is on and talking to a network can be located.
My take

That is exactly what I am doing right now. So I cannot go down there, and to be fair, I do not think most people should.

Notes and sources
The lesson people pull from Bazzell

If you really want privacy, do not be a public figure who talks about privacy.

The sea floorLayer 8 of 8Not your problem (probably)

Nation-state

Even an air gap leaks to an attacker who already got inside and is standing nearby.

What it costs

Time
Money
Friction

Who it is for

Militaries and the people they target. Not you and me.

Costs on a scale of 1 to 5, my working estimates.

What to do

  • Air-gap researchResearchers in Israel have shown that you can pull data out of an air-gapped computer through sound, through blinking LEDs, even through the radio noise coming off its memory.
  • The fine printEvery one of those attacks needs the machine to already be infected, and somebody standing nearby.
  • Zero riskThe box at the very bottom of the iceberg is empty on purpose, because zero risk does not exist. Even all the way down here.
My take

That is a military kind of problem. You and I do not need to worry about that one.

Sources

Sort your own life into three boxes

I am not picking one depth for my whole life. I am picking a depth for each piece of it. Tap a category, then tap the box it belongs in. On a computer you can also drag it.

The promise: this runs entirely in your browser. Nothing you sort or type here is sent anywhere, and nothing is saved unless you tick "Remember on this device".

Not sorted yet

Categories only. Do not type the actual details, like a real address or account name.

  • My face and name
  • Email
  • Password manager
  • Bank logins
  • ID scans
  • Tax returns
  • Medical records
  • Recovery codes
  • Journals
  • Family photos
  • Home address
  • Phone number
  • Work social profile

Public

Meant to be seen. Lax on purpose. The one rule: nothing in this box leads back home.

    Protected

    Has to be online to be useful, so it gets defended hard. Everything from the top of the iceberg goes here.

      Off the map

      Never on a network. Nobody can attack what they cannot reach.

        Hardware for this box

        A hardware-encrypted drive like the Kingston IronKey Keypad 200C for the files, and a small fire and water rated chest like the SentrySafe CHW20221 for the paper.

        Remembering uses this browser's local storage only. "Wipe everything" clears it and resets the boxes.

        How I sort mine (from the video)

        Public: my face, my name, the channel, the business, my gear, whatever I am learning that week.

        Protected: my email, the password manager, money, the account that owns the channel, my phone number. The keys, unique logins, the separate money email, the number lock and the credit freeze all live here. One extra rule for creators: I do not open sponsor files on the machine that is signed in to the channel. Google's threat team found a campaign with around 15,000 attacker accounts sending YouTubers fake sponsorship deals with malware that steals your login cookie, which skips your password and your two-factor completely. That is how a huge tech channel got hijacked back in 2023.

        Off the map: where my family lives, their faces and their details, the scans of my IDs, old tax returns, medical stuff, my recovery codes, my journals. None of that needs the internet to be useful, so it does not get the internet.

        The honest cost: offline means I am the backup plan. That is two copies in two places, a check once a year to make sure they still open, and somebody in my family who can get to it if I cannot. A single copy in one drawer is one fire away from being gone.

        Where convenience wins: I am not carrying a burner phone, and I am not giving up a normal phone for everyday stuff. I am not trying to be invisible. I want to be loud in the places where I chose to be public, boring everywhere else, and for the stuff that matters most, just not there at all.

        Source for the campaign: Google's Threat Analysis Group report on cookie theft malware aimed at YouTube creators.

        Where do I stop?

        Four quick questions, one suggested depth. This is my rule of thumb, not a verdict.

        Do you have an audience, a business or a public name?
        Do you handle other people's data?
        Have you been targeted before?
        How much friction will you tolerate?

        Answer all four to see a suggestion

        Everyone gets the top two layers no matter what: lock the front door, then tidy up.

        A rule of thumb, not advice. If you are facing a serious threat, like a stalker, an abusive ex or a government, do not rely on a quiz. Start with the EFF's Surveillance Self-Defense guide.

        About this page: it is a summary of other people's teaching and public guidance, not my own test of any tool. The cost meters are my working estimates. Lines marked "My take" are my opinion.

        Affiliate links may earn me a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.